• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Criminal Justice

iResearchNet




Criminal Justice > Criminology Theories > Critical Criminology > Critical Criminology and Gender

Critical Criminology and Gender




Critical criminology and gender examines how patriarchal power structures shape the definition, enforcement, and administration of criminal law, extending critical criminology’s foundational analysis of power and inequality to encompass gender as an independent axis of structural domination alongside class and race. Feminist critical criminologists have documented how gender shapes patterns of offending, victimization, and criminal justice processing in ways that mainstream, largely male-centered criminology historically neglected.

Introduction

Feminist criminology’s relationship to Critical Criminology developed partly in productive tension with the field’s earlier Marxist and radical currents, which feminist critics argued had focused overwhelmingly on class relations while treating gender as, at best, a secondary consideration subordinate to the primary analytical category of class. Carol Smart’s influential 1976 critique argued that mainstream criminology, including much radical criminology of the period, had been constructed around an implicitly male subject, treating male offending as the criminological norm requiring explanation while relegating female offending to marginal, often pathologizing treatment that assumed female criminality required distinct, typically biological or psychological rather than sociological, explanation.

This article traces feminist criminology’s emergence as a distinct strand within critical criminology, examines its core theoretical contributions concerning the gendered construction of criminal law and criminal justice institutions, surveys empirical research on gender differences in offending and victimization, and considers feminist criminology’s ongoing internal debates and its relationship to intersectional and queer criminological perspectives.




Emergence: Challenging Mainstream Criminology’s Male Subject

Feminist criminology emerged during the 1970s alongside the broader second-wave feminist movement, developing initially as a critique of mainstream criminology’s near-total neglect of female offending and victimization, a neglect feminist scholars argued reflected both the demographic reality that men committed the substantial majority of officially recorded crime and a deeper theoretical assumption that treated male experience as criminologically universal. Dorie Klein’s early feminist critique examined how existing theories of female criminality, to the limited extent such theories existed at all, relied on crude biological and psychological explanations, including theories linking female crime to menstruation, hormonal imbalance, or sexual maladjustment, explanations that received far less scrutiny than the more sophisticated sociological theories developed to explain male offending.

Freda Adler’s and Rita Simon’s competing liberation hypotheses, published in the mid-1970s, offered an early and influential, though ultimately contested, attempt to connect rising female crime rates to women’s expanding social and economic opportunities, proposing that as women gained greater access to employment and public life, their patterns of offending would increasingly converge with men’s. Subsequent feminist criminologists challenged both the empirical basis and the theoretical framing of the liberation hypothesis, arguing that it mistakenly treated crime as a marker of gender equality and that the modest rise in female arrest rates during this period reflected changes in law enforcement practice and the criminalization of economically motivated survival crime among poor women at least as much as any direct expansion of criminal opportunity accompanying women’s liberation.

Meda Chesney-Lind’s extensive research on girls and the juvenile justice system documented how gendered assumptions about appropriate female behavior shaped juvenile justice processing in ways that produced distinctively different outcomes for girls than for boys, particularly regarding status offenses, including running away and incorrigibility, that juvenile courts historically used to control girls’ sexuality and behavior in ways rarely applied with comparable intensity to boys engaged in analogous conduct. Chesney-Lind’s concept of the sexualization of girls’ delinquency captured how juvenile justice institutions treated ordinary adolescent behavior as requiring intervention specifically when exhibited by girls, reflecting underlying patriarchal assumptions about appropriate female conduct that shaped formal criminal justice processing independent of any comparably serious male conduct.

Feminist criminologists during this founding period also began documenting the substantial gap between women’s experiences as crime victims, particularly regarding domestic violence and sexual assault, and the criminal justice system’s historically inadequate response to these forms of victimization, research that helped establish violence against women as a legitimate object of criminological study rather than a private family matter largely outside the criminal justice system’s purview, as it had frequently been treated prior to feminist criminological and activist intervention during the 1970s and 1980s.

Theoretical Contributions: Patriarchy, Law, and the Construction of Female Criminality

Feminist critical criminologists developed several influential theoretical frameworks for analyzing how patriarchal power structures shape criminal law and criminal justice institutions. Carol Smart’s analysis of law as a gendered discourse argued that legal categories and legal reasoning themselves, not merely their discriminatory application, encode masculine assumptions about rationality, agency, and appropriate behavior that disadvantage women navigating the legal system, whether as defendants, victims, or witnesses, a claim that extended critical criminology’s broader analysis of law’s constructed and interested character specifically to gender.

Kathleen Daly and Meda Chesney-Lind’s influential synthesis of feminist criminological theory identified several core propositions shared broadly across feminist criminology, including the proposition that gender is not a natural, biological category but a socially constructed set of relations that vary across historical periods and cultural contexts, and the proposition that criminal justice institutions themselves actively produce and reinforce gender relations rather than merely responding to preexisting gender differences among offenders and victims. This constructionist orientation aligned feminist criminology with the broader critical criminological tradition’s skepticism toward naturalized categories, extending labeling theory’s and critical race theory’s constructionist insights specifically to gender.

Feminist critical criminologists have also examined the chivalry and evil woman hypotheses as competing accounts of how gender shapes criminal justice outcomes, with the chivalry hypothesis proposing that criminal justice institutions treat female offenders more leniently than male offenders reflecting paternalistic gender norms, while the evil woman hypothesis proposes that women who violate gender norms through their offending, particularly through violent crime, face harsher treatment precisely because their conduct doubly violates both the criminal law and expected feminine behavior. Empirical research testing these competing hypotheses has produced complex, context-dependent findings, with evidence supporting each hypothesis under different circumstances depending on offense type, and this literature increasingly emphasizes intersectional analysis recognizing that gender’s effect on criminal justice outcomes varies substantially by race and class as well.

Empirical Research: Gendered Patterns in Offending and Victimization

Feminist criminologists have generated extensive empirical research documenting substantial gender differences in patterns of offending, with women’s involvement in violent and property crime remaining consistently and substantially lower than men’s across virtually all available data sources and historical periods, a persistent pattern that feminist criminologists have explained through pathways theories examining how women’s distinctive routes into criminal offending, frequently involving prior victimization, economic marginalization, and substance abuse, differ systematically from men’s more commonly documented pathways into crime. Research on women’s pathways to incarceration has documented that the substantial majority of incarcerated women have prior histories of physical or sexual victimization, a pattern that feminist criminologists argue demands correctional and reentry programming responsive to trauma history rather than programming designed primarily around male offenders’ more commonly documented pathways into criminal offending.

Research on intimate partner violence and sexual assault has constituted a central empirical focus of feminist criminology since the field’s founding, documenting the persistent underreporting of these offenses to criminal justice authorities, the historically inadequate criminal justice response even when such offenses are reported, and the substantial reforms, including mandatory arrest policies for domestic violence and rape shield laws limiting the admissibility of victims’ sexual history in sexual assault prosecutions, that feminist criminological research and advocacy helped generate beginning in the 1970s and continuing through subsequent decades. Feminist criminologists have also documented significant unintended consequences of some of these reforms, including research demonstrating that mandatory arrest policies for domestic violence have sometimes resulted in the arrest of victims alongside or instead of primary aggressors, particularly in cases involving same-sex couples or where victims used force in self-defense, prompting ongoing feminist criminological reassessment of policy interventions initially developed with more simply protective intentions.

Correctional research within the feminist tradition has documented how women’s prisons and community corrections programs, historically designed around models developed for the numerically dominant male correctional population, frequently fail to address women’s distinctive needs regarding trauma history, primary caregiving responsibilities for children, and reproductive healthcare, generating a substantial body of feminist correctional research advocating for gender-responsive programming specifically designed around documented differences in incarcerated women’s backgrounds, needs, and pathways into the criminal justice system.

Ongoing Debates and Intersectional Extensions

Feminist criminology has engaged in sustained internal debate regarding the relationship between liberal, radical, socialist, and postmodern feminist theoretical frameworks, each offering distinct accounts of patriarchy’s relationship to criminal justice and correspondingly distinct policy implications, with liberal feminist approaches generally emphasizing formal legal equality and anti-discrimination remedies, radical feminist approaches emphasizing patriarchy as a freestanding system of male domination requiring fundamental transformation, and socialist feminist approaches examining patriarchy’s interaction with capitalist class relations in ways that connect more directly to Marxist critical criminology’s structural analysis.

Critical race and intersectional scholars, including Kimberlé Crenshaw and Beth Richie, have pressed feminist criminology to attend more consistently to how race and class shape women’s experiences of both victimization and criminalization, arguing that feminist criminology’s earlier theoretical frameworks, developed substantially by and with reference to white, middle-class women’s experiences, required significant revision to adequately address the distinctive experiences of women of color and poor women, whose relationship to criminal justice institutions differs in important respects from the experiences that founded much early feminist criminological theory.

Queer criminology’s emergence as a related but distinct critical perspective has further extended feminist criminology’s foundational insights regarding gender’s social construction to address sexuality and gender identity more explicitly, examining how heteronormative and cisnormative assumptions embedded within criminal law and criminal justice institutions produce distinctive patterns of criminalization and inadequate protection for LGBTQ populations that feminist criminology’s initial focus on the male-female binary did not fully anticipate, a development that reflects feminist criminology’s continuing theoretical evolution in productive dialogue with adjacent critical perspectives within the broader critical criminology field.

Conclusion

Feminist critical criminology has fundamentally transformed criminology’s treatment of gender, moving the discipline from near-total neglect of female offending and victimization during the pre-1970s period toward a substantial body of theory and research documenting how patriarchal power structures shape criminal law, criminal justice processing, and the lived experience of both female offenders and victims. From Carol Smart’s foundational critique of criminology’s implicitly male subject through Meda Chesney-Lind’s research on gendered juvenile justice processing to Beth Richie’s analysis of gender entrapment among incarcerated Black women, feminist criminology has generated theoretical and empirical contributions that have reshaped critical criminology’s broader understanding of power and inequality.

Feminist criminology’s ongoing engagement with intersectional and queer theoretical perspectives ensures that the field continues to evolve beyond its founding focus on the male-female binary, extending gender analysis to address the full complexity of how gender identity, sexuality, race, and class interact to shape individuals’ encounters with criminal law and criminal justice institutions, securing feminist criminology’s continuing centrality within the broader critical criminology field.

Related Articles

  • Intersectionality and Criminology
  • Critical Race Theory and Crime
  • Critical Criminology and Mass Incarceration
  • Origins and Development of Critical Criminology
  • Left Realism

References and Further Reading

  1. Belknap, J. (2020). The invisible woman: Gender, crime, and justice (5th ed.). Cengage Learning.
  2. Chesney-Lind, M. (1989). Girls’ crime and woman’s place: Toward a feminist model of female delinquency. Crime & Delinquency, 35(1), 5-29.
  3. Chesney-Lind, M., & Pasko, L. (2013). The female offender: Girls, women, and crime (3rd ed.). Sage.
  4. Daly, K. (1994). Gender, crime, and punishment. Yale University Press.
  5. Daly, K., & Chesney-Lind, M. (1988). Feminism and criminology. Justice Quarterly, 5(4), 497-538.
  6. DeKeseredy, W. S., & Schwartz, M. D. (2011). Theoretical and definitional issues in violence against women. In C. M. Renzetti, J. L. Edleson, & R. K. Bergen (Eds.), Sourcebook on violence against women (2nd ed., pp. 3-20). Sage.
  7. Gilfus, M. E. (1992). From victims to survivors to offenders: Women’s routes of entry and immersion into street crime. Women and Criminal Justice, 4(1), 63-89.
  8. Klein, D. (1973). The etiology of female crime: A review of the literature. Issues in Criminology, 8(2), 3-30.
  9. Mogul, J. L., Ritchie, A. J., & Whitlock, K. (2011). Queer (in)justice: The criminalization of LGBT people in the United States. Beacon Press.
  10. Owen, B. (1998). In the mix: Struggle and survival in a women’s prison. State University of New York Press.
  11. Renzetti, C. M. (2013). Feminist criminology. Routledge.
  12. Richie, B. E. (1996). Compelled to crime: The gender entrapment of battered Black women. Routledge.
  13. Richie, B. E. (2012). Arrested justice: Black women, violence, and America’s prison nation. New York University Press.
  14. Schwartz, M. D., & DeKeseredy, W. S. (1997). Sexual assault on the college campus: The role of male peer support. Sage.
  15. Smart, C. (1976). Women, crime, and criminology: A feminist critique. Routledge & Kegan Paul.
  16. Smart, C. (1989). Feminism and the power of law. Routledge.
  17. Van Wormer, K., & Bartollas, C. (2010). Women and the criminal justice system (3rd ed.). Pearson.
  18. Adler, F. (1975). Sisters in crime: The rise of the new female criminal. McGraw-Hill.
  19. Britton, D. M. (2003). At work in the iron cage: The prison as gendered organization. New York University Press.
  20. Bloom, B., Owen, B., & Covington, S. (2003). Gender-responsive strategies: Research, practice, and guiding principles for women offenders. National Institute of Corrections.
  21. Miller, S. L. (2001). The paradox of women arrested for domestic violence: Criminal justice professionals and service providers respond. Violence Against Women, 7(12), 1339-1376.
  22. Naffine, N. (1997). Feminism and criminology. Polity Press.
  23. Simon, R. J. (1975). Women and crime. Lexington Books.




Primary Sidebar

  • Facebook
  • GitHub
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Criminology Theories
    • Biological Theories of Crime
    • Biosocial Criminology
    • Broken Windows Theory
    • Classical Criminology
    • Conflict Theory
    • Convict Criminology
    • Criminal Careers
    • Criminal Justice Theories
    • Critical Criminology
      • Abolitionist Criminology
      • Anarchist Criminology
      • Critical Criminology and Criminal Justice Reform
      • Critical Criminology and Gender
      • Critical Criminology and Globalization
      • Critical Criminology and Human Rights
      • Critical Criminology and Mass Incarceration
      • Critical Criminology and Public Policy
      • Critical Criminology and State Crime
      • Critical Criminology and White-Collar Crime
      • Critical Race Theory and Crime
      • Criticisms of Critical Criminology
      • Intersectionality and Criminology
      • Left Realism
      • Marxist Criminology
      • Newsmaking Criminology and Public Criminology
      • Origins and Development of Critical Criminology
      • Postmodern Criminology
      • Power, Law, and Social Control
      • Right Realism
    • Cultural Criminology
    • Cultural Transmission Theory
    • Deterrence Theory
    • Differential Association Theory
    • Environmental Criminology
    • Feminist Criminology
    • Green Criminology
    • Integrated Theories of Crime
    • Labeling and Symbolic Interaction Theory
    • Life Course Criminology
    • Peacemaking Criminology
    • Psychological Theories of Crime
    • Queer Criminology
    • Rational Choice Theory
    • Routine Activities Theory
    • Self-Control Theory
    • Social Bond Theory
    • Social Construction Theory
    • Social Control Theory
    • Social Disorganization Theory
    • Social Learning Theory
    • Strain Theories of Crime
    • Subcultural Theory
    • Zemiology