Origins and development of critical criminology trace an intellectual trajectory that runs from the labeling and conflict theories of the 1960s through the explicitly Marxist radical criminology of the 1970s to the pluralistic, fragmented field now organized under the umbrella of Critical Criminology. Rather than emerging as a single coherent school, critical criminology took shape through a sequence of ruptures with mainstream positivist and consensus-based approaches to crime, each rupture adding new theoretical resources and new political commitments to a widening critical project.
Introduction
The historical formation of critical criminology cannot be understood apart from the broader climate of the late 1960s and early 1970s, a period in which challenges to established authority spread across sociology, history, and political science and reshaped how a generation of scholars approached the study of crime. Existing criminological theory at that time addressed the causes of individual offending largely within a framework that took the legitimacy of law and the existing social order for granted; it asked why particular individuals broke rules, not why the rules existed in the form they did or whom they served. The scholars who would eventually be identified as radical or critical criminologists broke with this framework by treating the definition of crime itself, and the operation of the criminal justice apparatus that enforced it, as objects of critical inquiry.
This article traces that formation across four analytically distinct but chronologically overlapping phases: the labeling and conflict antecedents that opened space for a structural critique of criminal law; the emergence of an explicitly radical criminology in the United States centered on the University of California, Berkeley; the parallel development of a British radical tradition associated with the National Deviancy Conference; and the fragmentation and diversification that followed the decline of a unified radical project in the 1980s, producing the pluralistic field now organized institutionally around the American Society of Criminology’s Division on Critical Criminology and Social Justice.
Antecedents: Labeling Theory and the Sociology of Deviance
Labeling theory, developed by scholars such as Howard Becker and Edwin Lemert during the 1960s, supplied an essential conceptual bridge between mainstream criminology and the radical criminology that followed. Becker’s Outsiders (1963) reframed deviance not as a quality inherent in an act but as a status conferred by social audiences with the power to apply and enforce rules, a move that shifted analytical attention away from the offender’s psychology and toward the processes by which some behaviors and some populations come to be criminalized while functionally similar behaviors among more privileged groups escape sanction. Lemert’s distinction between primary and secondary deviance further demonstrated how official processing itself, rather than any prior pathology, could produce durable criminal identities and careers.
Critical criminologists drew heavily on labeling theory’s insight that criminalization is a social and political process, but they also came to regard the perspective as analytically incomplete. Labeling theorists concentrated on face-to-face interactions between rule enforcers and rule breakers at the microlevel and had comparatively little to say about why particular rules existed in the first place or which macrostructural interests those rules served. This limitation became the point of departure for conflict criminology, associated with Thorsten Sellin, George Vold, and later Austin Turk, which located the origin of criminal law in the competition among groups for political power. Where labeling theory asked how deviant identities are constructed through interaction, conflict theory asked whose interests the criminal law encodes, and it was this latter question that radical and critical criminologists would push furthest.
By the end of the 1960s, the combination of labeling theory’s constructionist insight and conflict theory’s structural questions had produced a body of scholarship prepared to treat the criminal law, and not merely the criminal, as the proper object of criminological explanation. What remained absent from both traditions was a systematic account of the economic order underlying the distribution of power that conflict theorists described only in general terms. That account would arrive through the reception of Marxist theory into American and British criminology during the early 1970s, a development that transformed conflict criminology’s diffuse pluralism into a more focused critique of capitalist political economy.
This transitional moment was reinforced by the broader intellectual climate of the period, in which a resurgence of interest in Marxist and neo-Marxist social theory across sociology, history, and political science supplied criminologists with an established body of concepts ready for criminological application. Scholars entering graduate study in the early 1970s were exposed to this wider theoretical ferment well before they specialized in criminology, and many carried its influence directly into their subsequent criminological work, ensuring that the reception of Marxist theory into the field was not an isolated development but part of a much broader transformation of the social sciences during this period.
The Berkeley School and the Rise of Radical Criminology
The School of Criminology at the University of California, Berkeley became the principal institutional site of American radical criminology during the early 1970s. Faculty including Anthony Platt, Paul Takagi, Herman Schwendinger, and Julia Schwendinger developed a program of teaching and research that explicitly linked criminology to a broader critique of capitalism, racism, and the state’s coercive apparatus, positioning the school in direct opposition to the managerial and correctional orientation of mainstream criminal justice education. Platt’s earlier work on the invention of juvenile delinquency had already demonstrated how child-saving reformers of the Progressive Era extended state control over working-class youth under the guise of benevolence, and this genealogical method of exposing the class interests embedded in ostensibly humanitarian reforms became a signature move of Berkeley radical criminology.
Herman and Julia Schwendinger’s widely cited article proposing that criminology expand its subject matter beyond legally defined crime to encompass violations of basic human rights, including poverty, racism, sexism, and imperialism, pushed the Berkeley program toward its most expansive theoretical claim: that the legal definition of crime was itself an ideological artifact that obscured greater harms committed by the powerful. The Union of Radical Criminologists, formed in the early 1970s, provided an organizational vehicle for scholars sympathetic to this position, and the collectively authored volume The Iron Fist and the Velvet Glove (1975), produced by the Center for Research on Criminal Justice, offered an influential Marxist analysis of American policing that exemplified the school’s commitment to connecting scholarship with political praxis.
The Berkeley School’s confrontation with the university administration and with state political authorities intensified through the early 1970s, as radical faculty’s public criticism of police practices and of the Vietnam War drew hostile attention from California’s political establishment. The University of California Board of Regents voted to close the School of Criminology in 1974, a decision radical criminologists and their sympathizers interpreted as a direct consequence of the program’s political radicalism rather than any academic deficiency. The closure dispersed Berkeley-trained radical criminologists across other institutions, where many continued to develop the critical project that the school’s brief existence had helped launch, ensuring that the school’s influence persisted well beyond its institutional lifespan.
British Radical Criminology and the New Criminology
A parallel radical tradition developed in Britain out of the National Deviancy Conference, a series of meetings beginning in 1968 that brought together sociologists dissatisfied with the individualistic and correctionalist orientation of mainstream British criminology. Ian Taylor, Paul Walton, and Jock Young, key participants in this network, published The New Criminology: For a Social Theory of Deviance in 1973, a work that systematically critiqued the theoretical inadequacies of classical, positivist, and even existing labeling and conflict approaches to crime and called for a fully social theory that would connect the immediate circumstances of law-breaking to the wider political economy of capitalist society.
The New Criminology’s ambition was sweeping: its authors sketched what they termed a formal requirement for a complete criminological theory, one capable of explaining the wider origins of a deviant act, the immediate circumstances of the act itself, the process by which the actor and others interpret the act, the reaction of formal and informal control agencies, and the effects of that reaction on the actor’s subsequent action. This framework demanded an integration of structural, interactionist, and political-economic levels of analysis that few subsequent critical criminologists fully achieved, but the book’s programmatic call for such integration shaped the research agenda of British and, increasingly, international critical criminology throughout the following decade.
British radical criminology developed in closer proximity to organized left political movements than its American counterpart, and scholars associated with the tradition frequently engaged directly with trade union struggles, policing controversies, and debates within the British left about the proper relationship between criminology and revolutionary politics. This closer entanglement with contemporary political struggle gave British radical criminology a more explicitly interventionist character, visible in later collaborative projects such as Policing the Crisis (1978), led by Stuart Hall, which analyzed the 1970s moral panic over street robbery in Britain as a mechanism through which state authorities mobilized racialized fears of crime to legitimate an increasingly authoritarian response to broader economic and political crisis.
From Radical to Critical: Fragmentation and Diversification in the 1980s
The unified radical criminology of the early 1970s did not survive the decade intact. By the late 1970s and through the 1980s, the initial political energy that had animated the Berkeley School and the National Deviancy Conference had dissipated under the pressure of a changing political climate, in which conservative governments in both the United States and Britain proved considerably more resistant to radical critique than the movements of the preceding decade had anticipated. James Inciardi’s edited volume Radical Criminology: The Coming Crises (1980) captured this moment of reassessment, gathering both sympathetic and skeptical appraisals of the radical project’s achievements and limitations.
Several critical criminologists responded to this period of retrenchment by moving toward a more explicitly Marxist theoretical framework, seeking greater analytical rigor than the earlier, more eclectic radical criminology had achieved. Richard Quinney’s trajectory through Critique of Legal Order (1974) and Class, State, and Crime (1977) exemplified this movement toward systematic Marxist analysis, while other scholars turned instead toward left realism, developed by Jock Young and Roger Matthews in Britain and later by Walter DeKeseredy in Canada, which criticized radical criminology for what its proponents regarded as an insufficiently serious engagement with the real harm that street crime inflicted on working-class and minority communities.
This same period produced the term critical criminology itself, which increasingly displaced radical criminology in scholarly usage as the field diversified beyond its original Marxist and neo-Marxist core. Feminist criminologists including Carol Smart and Meda Chesney-Lind extended critical analysis to the gendered dimensions of crime and criminal justice that earlier radical criminology had largely neglected, while scholars working from postmodernist and constitutive frameworks, most notably Dragan Milovanovic and Stuart Henry, introduced poststructuralist theories of language, discourse, and meaning into the critical project. Peacemaking criminology, developed by Quinney and Harold Pepinsky, added a further strand emphasizing nonviolence and connectedness over the confrontational rhetoric of earlier radical criminology.
Institutionalization: The Division on Critical Criminology and Contemporary Critical Criminology
The formal institutionalization of critical criminology within mainstream criminological associations proceeded alongside this theoretical diversification. The American Society of Criminology’s Division on Critical Criminology, later renamed the Division on Critical Criminology and Social Justice, was established in 1988 and has since become one of the organization’s largest divisions, publishing the journal Critical Criminology and providing an institutional home for scholars whose theoretical commitments had once placed them at the margins of the discipline. This institutionalization marked a significant transformation in critical criminology’s relationship to mainstream criminology: a body of scholarship that had originated in direct opposition to establishment criminology, and whose most prominent early American exponents had seen their academic program shut down by university administrators, achieved durable representation within the discipline’s central professional organization.
The diversification that began in the 1980s has continued into the twenty-first century, with critical criminology now encompassing critical race theory, queer criminology, green criminology, convict criminology, and cultural criminology alongside its original Marxist, feminist, and left realist strands. Each of these later developments has extended critical criminology’s foundational commitment to analyzing the relationship between power and criminalization into new substantive domains, while continuing to share the field’s characteristic rejection of the claim that mainstream criminology offers a politically neutral account of crime and its control. What began as a series of scattered ruptures with positivist criminology in the late 1960s has become an established, institutionally secure, and theoretically pluralistic field, though one whose practitioners continue to debate how much unity the term critical criminology can meaningfully contain.
Academic publishing has tracked this institutional consolidation closely. Alongside Critical Criminology, journals including Social Justice and Contemporary Justice Review have provided regular venues for critical scholarship, while mainstream outlets such as Criminology and Justice Quarterly have increasingly published research employing explicitly critical frameworks, a development that would have seemed unlikely to the Berkeley faculty whose program was shuttered in 1974. Graduate programs at a number of universities now advertise critical criminology as an area of specialization, training successive cohorts of scholars in traditions that originated as marginal challenges to the discipline’s mainstream.
Conclusion
The development of critical criminology from its origins in labeling and conflict theory through the radical criminology of the Berkeley School and the National Deviancy Conference to the institutionalized pluralism of the present day illustrates a field shaped as much by political and institutional circumstance as by internal theoretical logic. The closure of the Berkeley School, the retrenchment of the 1980s, and the subsequent proliferation of feminist, postmodernist, and identity-focused strands were not incidental to critical criminology’s theoretical development but constitutive of it, forcing successive generations of scholars to reformulate the field’s foundational questions about power, law, and criminalization in response to changing political conditions.
Contemporary critical criminology retains from its origins a shared skepticism toward claims of value-neutral scientific objectivity in criminology and a shared commitment to connecting theoretical analysis with the exposure and, where possible, the amelioration of social injustice. Whether this shared orientation constitutes a truly unified field or merely a loose confederation of otherwise disparate theoretical projects remains a live question within critical criminology itself, one that reflects the same tension between diversity and coherence that has characterized the field since its fragmented origins in the late 1960s.
Related Articles
- Marxist Criminology
- Power, Law, and Social Control
- Postmodern Criminology
- Newsmaking Criminology and Public Criminology
- Criticisms of Critical Criminology
References and Further Reading
- Becker, H. S. (1963). Outsiders: Studies in the sociology of deviance. Free Press.
- Center for Research on Criminal Justice. (1975). The iron fist and the velvet glove: An analysis of the U.S. police. Center for Research on Criminal Justice.
- Chambliss, W. J. (1975). Toward a political economy of crime. Theory and Society, 2(2), 149-170.
- Chambliss, W. J., & Seidman, R. B. (1971). Law, order, and power. Addison-Wesley.
- Chesney-Lind, M. (1989). Girls’ crime and woman’s place: Toward a feminist model of female delinquency. Crime & Delinquency, 35(1), 5-29.
- DeKeseredy, W. S. (2011). Contemporary critical criminology. Routledge.
- Hall, S., Critcher, C., Jefferson, T., Clarke, J., & Roberts, B. (1978). Policing the crisis: Mugging, the state, and law and order. Macmillan.
- Henry, S., & Milovanovic, D. (1996). Constitutive criminology: Beyond postmodernism. Sage.
- Inciardi, J. A. (Ed.). (1980). Radical criminology: The coming crises. Sage.
- Lemert, E. M. (1951). Social pathology: A systematic approach to the theory of sociopathic behavior. McGraw-Hill.
- Lynch, M. J., & Michalowski, R. J. (2006). Primer in radical criminology: Critical perspectives on crime, power, and identity (4th ed.). Criminal Justice Press.
- Matthews, R., & Young, J. (Eds.). (1992). Issues in realist criminology. Sage.
- Pepinsky, H., & Quinney, R. (Eds.). (1991). Criminology as peacemaking. Indiana University Press.
- Platt, A. M. (1969). The child savers: The invention of delinquency. University of Chicago Press.
- Quinney, R. (1970). The social reality of crime. Little, Brown.
- Quinney, R. (1974). Critique of legal order: Crime control in capitalist society. Little, Brown.
- Quinney, R. (1977). Class, state, and crime. David McKay.
- Schwendinger, H., & Schwendinger, J. (1970). Defenders of order or guardians of human rights? Issues in Criminology, 5(2), 123-157.
- Sellin, T. (1938). Culture conflict and crime. Social Science Research Council.
- Smart, C. (1976). Women, crime, and criminology: A feminist critique. Routledge & Kegan Paul.
- Taylor, I., Walton, P., & Young, J. (1973). The new criminology: For a social theory of deviance. Routledge & Kegan Paul.
- Turk, A. T. (1969). Criminality and the legal order. Rand McNally.
- Vold, G. B. (1958). Theoretical criminology. Oxford University Press.
- Young, J. (1986). The failure of criminology: The need for a radical realism. In R. Matthews & J. Young (Eds.), Confronting crime (pp. 4-30). Sage.