Postmodern criminology applies poststructuralist and postmodernist theories of language, discourse, and knowledge to the study of crime and criminal justice, challenging the modernist assumptions of objectivity, universal truth, and stable meaning that underlie both mainstream criminology and much of critical criminology’s own structural analysis. Rather than offering a unified alternative theory of crime, postmodern criminology functions primarily as a critical method, deconstructing the taken-for-granted categories, including crime, criminal, and justice, through which criminology and criminal justice institutions organize their understanding of social reality.
Introduction
Postmodern criminology’s relationship to Critical Criminology is theoretically complicated by the fact that classical postmodernist thought is not inherently progressive or emancipatory in its political orientation, unlike the Marxist and feminist perspectives that constitute much of the critical criminology field; postmodernism’s rejection of totalizing narratives extends skepticism even toward the emancipatory metanarratives, including the promise of socialist transformation or universal human rights, that motivate other strands of critical criminology. Postmodern criminologists have nonetheless developed distinctively critical applications of postmodernist theory, using deconstructive method to expose the constructed and contestable character of criminal justice categories that mainstream criminology treats as natural or self-evident.
This article traces postmodern criminology’s theoretical origins in French poststructuralist philosophy, examines constitutive criminology as its most fully developed criminological application, considers postmodern criminology’s distinctive method of deconstructing legal and criminological language, and addresses the sustained criticism postmodern criminology has faced from other strands of critical criminology regarding its practical and political implications.
Theoretical Origins: Poststructuralism and the Critique of Modernist Knowledge
Postmodern criminology draws its philosophical foundations primarily from French poststructuralist theory developed by Michel Foucault, Jacques Derrida, and Jean-François Lyotard during the 1960s and 1970s, thinkers who, despite considerable differences among their individual projects, shared a common skepticism toward the Enlightenment assumption that reason and scientific method could produce objective, universal knowledge independent of the discursive and institutional contexts within which that knowledge is produced. Lyotard’s influential characterization of the postmodern condition as incredulity toward metanarratives captured this broader skepticism toward totalizing theoretical frameworks, including Marxism, that claim to explain social reality through a single, all-encompassing account of historical development and social structure.
Derrida’s method of deconstruction, which examines how texts and discourses depend on unstable binary oppositions, including crime and innocence or normal and deviant, that cannot be sustained under close analytical scrutiny, provided postmodern criminologists with an analytical technique for exposing the constructed and contestable character of the legal and criminological categories that structure criminal justice practice. Rather than accepting that categories such as crime possess stable, self-evident meaning, deconstructive analysis reveals how such categories depend on suppressed or marginalized alternative meanings that could, under different discursive and institutional arrangements, organize social understanding quite differently.
Foucault’s own work, particularly Discipline and Punish (1975) and his later writing on governmentality, has exerted the single greatest influence on postmodern and poststructuralist criminology, though Foucault’s relationship to postmodernism proper remains contested among scholars, since Foucault himself resisted easy classification as a postmodernist. Foucault’s analysis of how disciplinary power operates through the production of knowledge about criminalized populations, generating categories of delinquency, deviance, and dangerousness that both classify and construct the subjects they purport merely to describe, provided a model for postmodern criminological analysis that numerous subsequent scholars have extended and adapted.
Jean Baudrillard’s writing on simulation and hyperreality, though less directly influential within criminology than Foucault’s work, has informed postmodern criminological analysis of how media representations of crime increasingly displace and even substitute for direct public experience of crime, producing a public understanding of criminality shaped substantially by mediated images and narratives rather than by direct encounter with either offenders or victims. This Baudrillardian strand of postmodern criminology connects to broader critical concerns about the relationship between crime, media, and public perception that cultural and newsmaking criminology have also addressed from complementary theoretical angles.
Constitutive Criminology: Henry and Milovanovic’s Synthesis
Stuart Henry and Dragan Milovanovic developed constitutive criminology during the 1990s as the most systematic effort to construct a distinctively postmodernist criminological theory, published most fully in their 1996 book Constitutive Criminology: Beyond Postmodernism. Henry and Milovanovic argued that crime and its control should be understood as mutually constitutive processes, in which offenders, victims, control agents, and criminologists themselves collectively co-produce the meaning of crime through ongoing discursive practice, rather than crime existing as a stable, pre-given category that criminal justice institutions and criminological research subsequently describe and explain.
Constitutive criminology’s central concept of the crime of reduction and the crime of repression describes how criminal harm operates by diminishing the standing or agency of victims, whether through direct physical or material reduction or through symbolic and discursive repression that denies victims’ full humanity or social recognition, a formulation that Henry and Milovanovic argued applied not only to conventional interpersonal crime but also to the harms inflicted by powerful institutions, including corporations and states, that postmodern analysis renders visible in ways that conventional legal categories often obscure.
Henry and Milovanovic’s constitutive approach explicitly positioned itself as a synthesis of postmodernist method and critical criminology’s emancipatory political commitments, arguing that deconstructing the discursive foundations of existing criminal justice categories served a progressive political function by revealing the contingency, and therefore the changeability, of arrangements that mainstream criminology treats as natural and inevitable. This synthesis distinguished constitutive criminology from more politically ambivalent applications of postmodernist theory, positioning Henry and Milovanovic’s work as a self-consciously critical rather than merely descriptive or analytical postmodern criminology.
Deconstructing Legal and Criminological Language
Postmodern criminologists have applied deconstructive method extensively to legal language and criminal justice discourse, examining how the ostensibly neutral and technical vocabulary of law, including terms such as reasonable person, intent, and dangerousness, encodes particular, historically and culturally specific assumptions about normal behavior and rational agency that disadvantage populations, including racial minorities, women, and people with mental illness, whose experiences and modes of expression diverge from the implicit norms embedded in legal categories. This deconstructive analysis of legal language connects postmodern criminology to feminist and critical race scholarship that has similarly examined how ostensibly neutral legal categories encode gendered and racialized assumptions.
Postmodern criminologists have extended deconstructive analysis to media and popular representations of crime, examining how news coverage, true crime narratives, and political rhetoric construct particular images of criminality, dangerousness, and victimhood that shape public understanding of crime in ways that often diverge substantially from empirical patterns of offending and victimization, a line of analysis that connects postmodern criminology to the newsmaking criminology tradition and to cultural criminology’s broader concern with the symbolic and representational dimensions of crime and its control.
Sentencing and risk assessment discourse has received particular postmodern critical attention, since the technical, seemingly objective language of actuarial risk assessment, increasingly deployed in bail, sentencing, and parole decisions, obscures the discretionary and often racially disparate judgments embedded within risk categories that present themselves as neutral statistical classification rather than as contestable social and political determinations, an analysis that anticipates and informs contemporary critical scrutiny of algorithmic decision-making in criminal justice.
Criticisms and the Contested Legacy of Postmodern Criminology
Postmodern criminology has faced sustained criticism from other strands of critical criminology, particularly from Marxist and left realist criminologists who argue that postmodernism’s skepticism toward totalizing metanarratives undermines the capacity for the kind of structural, materialist analysis that Marxist and left realist criminology regard as essential for understanding the systemic character of crime and criminal justice inequality. Critics have argued that an exclusive focus on discourse and language risks diverting critical attention away from the material conditions, including poverty, unemployment, and institutional racism, that structural critical criminologists regard as the primary drivers of both crime and criminal justice inequality.
Left realist critics, including Jock Young, have argued more pointedly that postmodern criminology’s relentless deconstruction of stable categories, including the category of crime itself, threatens to reproduce the same left idealist tendency that left realism originally arose to correct, one that treats crime and victimization as insufficiently real or urgent to warrant direct empirical and policy engagement. This criticism echoes broader concerns within critical criminology that postmodernism’s political ambivalence, its refusal to specify a positive political program beyond the deconstruction of existing categories, limits its usefulness for criminologists committed to concrete policy reform or political transformation.
Postmodern criminologists have responded to these criticisms by arguing that deconstructive analysis need not preclude structural or empirical analysis but can instead complement such analysis by revealing the discursive mechanisms through which structural inequality is naturalized and legitimated, a defense that has found particular resonance in subsequent intersectional and critical race scholarship that combines structural analysis of race, class, and gender inequality with attention to the discursive and representational dimensions of criminalization that postmodern method was specifically developed to address.
Conclusion
Postmodern criminology’s distinctive contribution to critical criminology lies in its deconstructive method, which exposes the constructed, contingent, and often discriminatory character of the legal and criminological categories that both mainstream and, at times, critical criminology treat as stable and self-evident. Constitutive criminology’s synthesis of postmodernist theory with critical criminology’s emancipatory political commitments, developed most systematically by Henry and Milovanovic, demonstrates that deconstructive method can be harnessed toward explicitly progressive political ends rather than remaining confined to politically ambivalent academic analysis.
Despite sustained criticism from Marxist and left realist critical criminologists concerning its relationship to structural and empirical analysis, postmodern criminology’s influence persists in contemporary critical scrutiny of legal language, media representation, and algorithmic risk assessment, ensuring that deconstructive method remains an active resource within the broader critical criminology field even as debates over its political and practical implications continue.
Related Articles
- Critical Race Theory and Crime
- Power, Law, and Social Control
- Left Realism
- Origins and Development of Critical Criminology
- Intersectionality and Criminology
References and Further Reading
- Arrigo, B. A. (1995). The peripheral core of law and criminology: On postmodern social theory and conceptual integration. Justice Quarterly, 12(3), 447-472.
- Arrigo, B. A., & Bernard, T. J. (1997). Postmodern criminology in relation to radical and conflict criminology. Critical Criminology, 8(2), 39-60.
- Derrida, J. (1978). Writing and difference (A. Bass, Trans.). University of Chicago Press.
- Ferrell, J., Hayward, K., & Young, J. (2015). Cultural criminology: An invitation (2nd ed.). Sage.
- Foucault, M. (1977). Discipline and punish: The birth of the prison. Pantheon Books.
- Foucault, M. (1991). Governmentality. In G. Burchell, C. Gordon, & P. Miller (Eds.), The Foucault effect: Studies in governmentality (pp. 87-104). University of Chicago Press.
- Hall, S. (1997). Representation: Cultural representations and signifying practices. Sage.
- Harcourt, B. E. (2007). Against prediction: Profiling, policing, and punishing in an actuarial age. University of Chicago Press.
- Henry, S., & Milovanovic, D. (1996). Constitutive criminology: Beyond postmodernism. Sage.
- Henry, S., & Milovanovic, D. (Eds.). (1999). Constitutive criminology at work: Applications to crime and justice. State University of New York Press.
- Lyotard, J. F. (1984). The postmodern condition: A report on knowledge (G. Bennington & B. Massumi, Trans.). University of Minnesota Press.
- Milovanovic, D. (1997). Postmodern criminology. Garland Publishing.
- Pfohl, S. (1993). Revenge of the parasites: Feeding off the ruins of Sutherland’s differential association. In G. Barak (Ed.), Varieties of criminology (pp. 121-136). Praeger.
- Schwartz, M. D., & Friedrichs, D. O. (1994). Postmodern thought and criminological discontent: New metaphors for understanding violence. Criminology, 32(2), 221-246.
- Smart, C. (1990). Feminist approaches to criminology or postmodern woman meets atavistic man. In L. Gelsthorpe & A. Morris (Eds.), Feminist perspectives in criminology (pp. 70-84). Open University Press.
- Young, J. (1999). The exclusive society: Social exclusion, crime, and difference in late modernity. Sage.
- Baudrillard, J. (1994). Simulacra and simulation (S. F. Glaser, Trans.). University of Michigan Press.
- Cohen, S. (2002). Folk devils and moral panics: The creation of the mods and rockers (3rd ed.). Routledge.
- Ferrell, J. (2001). Tearing down the streets: Adventures in urban anarchy. Palgrave Macmillan.
- Presdee, M. (2000). Cultural criminology and the carnival of crime. Routledge.
- Surette, R. (2015). Media, crime, and criminal justice: Images, realities, and policies (5th ed.). Cengage Learning.
- Williams, C. R., & Arrigo, B. A. (2002). Law, psychology, and justice: Chaos theory and the new (dis)order. State University of New York Press.